Move Trust Hub
INDEPENDENT DOI-VERIFIED DIRECTORY · NO PAID PLACEMENTS
Find AgentsToolsCalculatorsGuidesHealth HubsAboutContactFind Agents
Home / Health Insurance Hubs / Indiana / Indianapolis

Verified · Independent · Licensed Only

Top Verified Insurance Agents in Indianapolis

Health Insurance Experts Serving healthcare, logistics, and Indy 500 corridor families

12 agencies · 8 health specialists · Avg trust score 91/100 · 568 reviews analyzed

ZIP search auto-detects your county/MSA and ranks local verified agents. 100% data-driven — never sponsored.

Local Market Snapshot

Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson across Marion, Hamilton, Hendricks, Johnson, and Hancock counties combines healthcare employment benefits expertise with Indiana marketplace enrollment, logistics-worker ACA demand, and fast-growing suburban Medicare in Carmel, Fishers, and Avon corridors.

2.1M

Metro population

high

Health insurance density

91/100

Avg trust score

Enrollment highlight: Healthcare and logistics corridor with growing capital-city suburbs

  • Healthcare system employee benefits
  • Indiana marketplace ACA enrollment
  • Carmel/Fishers suburban group plans
  • Marion County Medicare
  • Logistics corridor health plans
  • IU Health network alignments

Indianapolis Metro Coverage Area

12 verified independent agencies across Marion, Hamilton, Hendricks, Johnson, and Hancock counties — 8 with primary health/Medicare/ACA/group emphasis and 4 multi-line independents. Healthcare employment benefits, Indiana marketplace enrollment, and growing capital-city suburban demand. Average Google rating ~4.8–5.0 stars.

MarionHamiltonHendricksJohnsonHancockHealthcare corridor · Indiana marketplace · Carmel suburbs
Verified insurance agents in Indianapolis — sortable comparison table
#Agency / ContactCity & CountyLicenseHealth FocusRatingTrust
1
Jason Hark, MBA, CMIP
(317) 567-3344
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
5.0 (49)85/100
2
Indyhealthagent
(317) 482-7063
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Employer/GroupACA Marketplace
4.9 (58)71/100
3
Michael Wehner
(317) 495-3211
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
5.0 (54)85/100
4
Andrew Sandlin
(317) 687-4052
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
5.0 (27)83/100
5
Chris Koehl
(463) 304-8799
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
5.0 (4)83/100
6
Candace McWilliams
(317) 825-7539
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
4.8 (153)86/100
7
Theresa Blacketer
(317) 825-7550
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
5.0 (2)83/100
8
Teresa Smith
(317) 825-7343
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageMedicare Supplement
5.0 (2)91/100
9
Laurie Gates
(317) 825-7641
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageACA Marketplace
5.0 (92)85/100
10
J C Smith Insurance Agency
Judy Smith
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageACA Marketplace
3.5 (4)77/100
11
Strategic Insurance Inc
Rodney Stuart
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageACA Marketplace
5.0 (4)96/100
12
Med Insure Your Way LLC
Richard Thoben
Indianapolis, IN
Marion County
IN-DOI Active ✅
Medicare AdvantageACA Marketplace
4.8 (36)79/100

✅ = DFS license confirmed where noted · Verify current status at Florida DFS Licensee Search and NIPR/NAIC producer lookup.

Health Insurance Specialists in Indianapolis

Top 3 featured: Jason Hark · Indyhealthagent · Michael Wehner

Showing 8 of 8 agencies

1

Teresa Smith

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(2 reviews)

#7 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare agent from Medicare Agents Hub offering independent Advantage, Medigap, and Part D guidance for metro seniors and logistics-corridor families.

Patient Medicare counseling with strong annual plan review support across the Indianapolis metro.

Recognition: #7 Top Rated Indianapolis Agent

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 91/100
Local Market Experience: 91/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A+
(317) 825-7343Contact AgencyView Profile
2

Jason Hark, MBA, CMIPMedicare Insurance Options LLC

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(49 reviews)

#1 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare broker (Medicare Agents Hub), MBA and CMIP-certified offering independent Advantage, Medigap, Part D, and Indiana marketplace comparisons for Marion County seniors and healthcare-corridor families.

Organized, professional, and thorough — explained Medicare on terms we could understand and removed enrollment stress across Indianapolis.

Recognition: #1 Top Rated Indianapolis Broker · CMIP Certified · MBA

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Life
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 85/100
Local Market Experience: 97/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A+
(317) 567-3344Contact AgencyView Profile
3

Michael Wehner

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(54 reviews)

#2 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare agent from Medicare Agents Hub with personalized Advantage, supplement, and Indiana marketplace guidance for metro seniors and healthcare-employment retirees.

Positive client feedback for thorough Medicare reviews and enrollment assistance across the Indianapolis metro.

Recognition: #2 Top Rated Indianapolis Agent

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 85/100
Local Market Experience: 96/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A+
(317) 495-3211Contact AgencyView Profile
4

Andrew Sandlin

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(27 reviews)

#3 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare agent from Medicare Agents Hub serving Marion County with Advantage, Medigap, and Part D comparisons.

Accessible Medicare enrollment praised by Indianapolis metro seniors and suburban retirees.

Recognition: #3 Top Rated Indianapolis Agent

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 83/100
Local Market Experience: 95/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB B-
(317) 687-4052Contact AgencyView Profile
5

Chris Koehl

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(4 reviews)

#4 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare agent from Medicare Agents Hub with local Advantage, supplement, and marketplace expertise for central Marion County.

Trusted for patient Medicare counseling and annual plan review support in the Indianapolis area.

Recognition: #4 Top Rated Indianapolis Agent

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 83/100
Local Market Experience: 94/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A
(463) 304-8799Contact AgencyView Profile
6

Theresa Blacketer

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(2 reviews)

#6 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare broker from Medicare Agents Hub with local Advantage, supplement, and ACA marketplace support for healthcare-corridor commuters.

Positive client feedback for thorough Medicare reviews and enrollment assistance in Marion County.

Recognition: #6 Top Rated Indianapolis Broker

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 83/100
Local Market Experience: 92/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A
(317) 825-7550Contact AgencyView Profile
7

Indyhealthagent

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

4.9(58 reviews)

Local independent health and Medicare agency serving Marion County with individual, family, and senior plan comparisons — trusted Indy metro broker for Advantage, supplements, and Indiana marketplace enrollment.

Strong client service praised for accessible health and Medicare guidance across Indianapolis neighborhoods.

Recognition: Marion County local specialist · Independent health & Medicare agency

Employer/Group
ACA Marketplace
Medicare Advantage
Life
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 71/100
Local Market Experience: 96/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A+
(317) 482-7063Contact AgencyView Profile
8

Candace McWilliams

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

4.8(153 reviews)

#5 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare agent from Medicare Agents Hub offering independent Advantage, Medigap, and Part D guidance for metro seniors.

Highly recommended for personalized Medicare comparisons across Indianapolis neighborhoods.

Recognition: #5 Top Rated Indianapolis Agent

Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA Marketplace
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 86/100
Local Market Experience: 93/100
Avg Response: <2h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A
(317) 825-7539Contact AgencyView Profile

Full Directory — Multi-Line Agencies

Home, auto, life, and commercial partners serving Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson

Showing 4 of 4 agencies

9

Strategic Insurance Inc

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(4 reviews)

Northeast Indianapolis independent multi-line agency with Medicare and health cross-sell for Broad Ripple, Keystone, and northern Marion County suburban families and contractors.

Trusted northeast-metro agency for Medicare referrals and personal-lines bundling along the Keystone corridor.
Medicare Advantage
ACA Marketplace
Employer/Group
Auto
Homeowners
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 96/100
Local Market Experience: 90/100
Avg Response: <3h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A+ · Accredited
Contact AgencyView Profile
10

Laurie Gates

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

5.0(92 reviews)

#8 top-rated Indianapolis Medicare broker from Medicare Agents Hub with multi-line cross-sell for Marion County families, small businesses, and suburban employers along the I-465 corridor.

Trusted Indianapolis agency for Medicare referrals and personal-lines bundling across Marion County.

Recognition: #8 Top Rated Indianapolis Broker

Medicare Advantage
ACA Marketplace
Employer/Group
Auto
Homeowners
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 85/100
Local Market Experience: 92/100
Avg Response: <3h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A
(317) 825-7641Contact AgencyView Profile
11

Med Insure Your Way LLC

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

4.8(36 reviews)

Northeast Indianapolis independent Medicare and health agency with cross-sell for Castleton, Fishers overflow, and eastern Marion County suburban retirees and small businesses.

Local eastern Marion support for Medicare and health plan transitions near the 46256 employment corridor.
Medicare Advantage
ACA Marketplace
Employer/Group
Life
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 79/100
Local Market Experience: 89/100
Avg Response: <3h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A+
Contact AgencyView Profile
12

J C Smith Insurance Agency

Indianapolis · IN · Marion County · Serves Indianapolis

3.5(4 reviews)

West-side Indianapolis independent multi-line agency with Medicare and health cross-sell for Speedway-area families, small businesses, and western Marion County suburban employers.

Accessible west Indianapolis support for Medicare and personal-lines coverage near the 46224 corridor.
Medicare Advantage
ACA Marketplace
Employer/Group
Auto
Homeowners
Featured Medicare/ACA
License: IN-DOI Active ✅
Trust Score: 77/100
Local Market Experience: 91/100
Avg Response: <3h
DOI VerifiedNAIC Verified · BBB A
Contact AgencyView Profile

Compare Licensed Insurance Agencies

Independent matching in Indianapolis. No paid placements.

By submitting, you agree we may share your inquiry with verified listed agents for research purposes. Not insurance advice. Verify all licenses independently.

Why Local Matters

State licensing, network adequacy, and subsidy rules vary by county. Local agents in Indianapolis understand Indiana DOI requirements and carrier appointments specific to your ZIP code.

DOI VerifiedNAIC DataBBB RatedNo Paid Ads

Filter by Coverage

Health/Medicare/ACAAutoHomeLifeCommercialIndependent

How It Works

Your Path to the Right Agent

Three steps to discover honest local insurance experts with transparent, data-driven listings.

01

Search Your ZIP

Enter your ZIP code to auto-detect your county and MSA. See ranked local agents with health insurance specialists highlighted for ACA, Medicare, and employer plans.

02

Compare & Verify

Review Trust Scores, state DOI licensing, NAIC verification, BBB ratings, and attributed reviews. We analyze public records — never sponsored placements.

03

Connect Securely

Use our calculators to understand your numbers, then connect with independent agents who specialize in your coverage needs. Always verify licensing before engaging.

Independent directory. Not affiliated with any insurance carrier, agency, or agent. All information is for research purposes only. Always verify licensing directly with your state's Department of Insurance, NAIC, or official sources before engaging any provider.

Related independent directories

Related independent research when coverage changes with a move — same no paid placements approach.

  • Find movers on MoveTrustHub
  • Moving guides
Move Trust Hub

Independent, verified insurance agent directory — no paid placements.

DIRECTORY
All Agents
Health Hubs
Browse by State
Destinations
TOOLS
License Verification
ACA Subsidy Calculator
Medicare Plan Finder
Needs Assessment
All Calculators
GUIDES
All Guides
Verify an Agent License
Choose an Insurance Agent
Medicare Advantage vs Medigap
Choose a Health Plan
How We Verify
COMPANY & LEGAL
About
Contact
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
NAIC ↗
TRUST & TRANSPARENCY

Independent directory — not affiliated with listed providers. No lead fees. No paid placements. Data for research only.

hello@movetrusthub.com

© 2026 InsuranceTrustHub

Part of the ConsumerTrust Hub network. MoveTrustHub · LenderTrustHub (coming soon)

Always verify licensing directly with NAIC and state authorities.